Flag of holy see Holy See vs Flag of israel Israel

International relations comparison · updated Nov 2026

Holy See: also called Vatican City, Vatican.

7.14 / 10
Good

The relation between Holy See and Israel is GOOD, with an overall score of 7.14 out of 10.

Chance of conflict between both countries: very rare

Do our numbers match your view?
Combined score 6.7/10 · 1 vote · 100.0% say "worse"

Head to head: who leads each category

Population
Holy See 801
Israel 10.1M Leads
Global influence rank
Holy See #49
Israel #5 Leads

About this relationship

The Fundamental Agreement between Israel and the Holy See is a distinctive bilateral tie shaped far more by religious history and theological symbolism than by conventional statecraft, formally established only in the early 1990s after nearly two millennia during which the papacy maintained no diplomatic recognition of a Jewish state in the Holy Land. For decades after Israel's founding in 1948, the Vatican withheld recognition, citing unresolved questions over the status of Jerusalem and the broader Israeli-Palestinian dispute. This changed with the landmark Fundamental Agreement signed on 30 December 1993, which paved the way for full diplomatic relations in 1994, the exchange of ambassadors, and the opening of an apostolic nunciature in Jerusalem, ending centuries of formal estrangement.

The Fundamental Agreement remains the foundational legal instrument governing the relationship, obliging Israel to guarantee the Catholic Church's freedom of religion and conscience and its right to operate educational, charitable, and media institutions, while affirming the legal personality of Church bodies in the country. Implementation proceeded through supplementary accords, including a 1997 Legal Personality Agreement and a 2015 agreement, concluded after roughly two decades of negotiation, addressing fiscal exemptions and property matters affecting Church-owned land. These instruments regulate the status of holdings belonging to the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem, the Franciscan Custody of the Holy Land, and numerous religious orders, enabling the Church to run schools, hospitals, and shrines across Israeli territory.

Diplomatically, the relationship has been repeatedly tested by the Holy See's positions on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the status of Jerusalem, which the Vatican has long insisted requires internationally guaranteed protections for its holy sites and free access for all three monotheistic faiths. Tensions escalated sharply after the Gaza war began in October 2023, as Pope Francis made nightly phone calls to Gaza's Holy Family Parish and, before his death in April 2025, questioned aspects of the conflict's conduct, drawing sharp Israeli rebukes. Friction peaked in July 2025 when Israeli tank fire struck the church itself, killing and wounding parishioners; Israel expressed regret and pledged an investigation, while newly elected Pope Leo XIV condemned the "barbarity" and renewed calls for a ceasefire.

The relationship's deepest dimension remains religious: Israel hosts sites central to Christian tradition, including the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem, the shores of the Sea of Galilee, Nazareth, and the Mount of Beatitudes, many entrusted since the fourteenth century to the Franciscan Custody of the Holy Land. Christian pilgrimage traffic, once numbering well over a million visitors annually before 2023, collapsed amid the Gaza war and regional instability, recovering only gradually as overall tourist arrivals to Israel approached 1.3 million in 2025. Israel's small Christian population, roughly two percent of citizens, includes Latin, Melkite Greek, and Maronite Catholic communities served by the Patriarchate.

High-level exchanges have punctuated the relationship since normalization, including Pope John Paul II's landmark Jubilee pilgrimage in 2000, Pope Benedict XVI's 2009 visit, and Pope Francis's 2014 trip, during which he prayed at the Western Wall. Pope Leo XIV, elected in May 2025 following Francis's death, continued this pattern of engagement, discussing Gaza and a prospective two-state solution with Israeli President Isaac Herzog. Overall, Israel-Holy See relations remain a narrow but symbolically weighty channel, defined less by trade or security cooperation than by the management of sacred sites, minority Christian rights, and recurring diplomatic friction over the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

·
801
Population
10.1MLeads
1 km²
Land area
20.3K km²Leads
Vatican City
Capital
Jerusalem
Christianity
Main religion
Judaism
79 years
Life expectancy
83 years

Strengths & comparison

Population Israel is 12,638x larger
Land area Israel is 20,330x larger

The position in the international influence ranking of Israel is 5, while Holy See is situated 44 places below in the ranking (position 49). Israel maintains contact with 158 countries, while Holy See maintains contact with 62 countries. Israel maintains an excellent relation with 1 countries, while in the case of Holy See, this figure drops to 0.

About Holy See

The Holy See is the jurisdiction of the Catholic Church in Rome, and it is a sovereign entity recognized by international law. The Holy See is not a state, but it has diplomatic relations with many countries and is a permanent observer to various international organizations, including the United Nations. The Holy See is headed by the Pope, who is the Bishop of Rome and the leader of the worldwide Catholic Church. The Pope is assisted in the governance of the Church by the Roman Curia, which is a complex bureaucracy that includes various departments and offices responsible for different aspects of the Church's administration. The Holy See also has a number of embassies and other diplomatic missions around the world, and it is involved in various charitable and humanitarian initiatives.

Geography & terrain

An urban micro-enclave entirely within the city of Rome, with essentially no natural terrain of its own — no hills, rivers, or open land beyond a few city blocks. Mediterranean climate by virtue of its setting. Landlocked, no coastline, and wholly surrounded by Italy; it has no meaningful defensive terrain and relies entirely on diplomatic status rather than geography for its security.

About Israel

Israel is a small country located in the Middle East, on the eastern shore of the Mediterranean Sea. It is bordered by Lebanon to the north, Syria to the northeast, Jordan and the West Bank to the east, and Egypt and the Gaza Strip to the southwest.

Israel is a parliamentary democracy. The official languages are Hebrew and Arabic, and the currency is the Israeli shekel.

Israel has a complex and often tumultuous history, and its modern political landscape is shaped by its position as a predominantly Jewish state in a region with a large Arab population. Relations between Israel and its neighbors have been strained at times, and the country has been involved in several wars and conflicts over the years.

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been a major source of tension in the region for decades. Israel's occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, territories that are home to a large Palestinian population, has been a particularly contentious issue. Efforts to reach a peaceful resolution to the conflict have been ongoing for many years, but have so far been unsuccessful.

Israel is also involved in regional politics and has strong ties with the United States, which is a major ally and provider of military aid. Israel is a member of several international organizations, including the United Nations and the World Trade Organization.

Geography & terrain

A narrow Mediterranean coastal plain gives way to central hills, the Jordan Rift Valley, and the arid Negev desert in the south. Mostly Mediterranean climate, turning desert further south. Has a Mediterranean coastline. The narrow width leaves little strategic depth, but the eastern high ground overlooking the Jordan Valley has real defensive value, making that terrain a historic strategic prize.

Source: World Bank Open Data. Most recent available data
Holy See Israel
Government type Absolute elective monarchy Parliamentary republic
GDP Data not available $610.8B
GDP per capita Data not available $60.3K
Military expenditure Data not available $46.5B
Military expenditure per capita Data not available $4.6K
Land military expenditure (estimation) n/a $18.6B
Air military expenditure (estimation) n/a $18.6B
Naval military expenditure (estimation) n/a $9.3B
Nuclear power No Yes
European Union Not a member Not a member
NATO Not a member Not a member

The capitals of Holy See and Israel are approximately 2 307 km apart (straight-line distance). There is a standard time difference of about 1.0 hours between them.

Based on shared language, currency, economic profile, borders and international groups, Holy See and Israel score a 0/100 similarity index. The index combines these five structural factors: it describes how alike the two countries are, not how good their relationship is.

Which side is each country closer to?

Map legend
Closer to Holy See Closer to Israel

Comparing Holy See's and Israel's scores against the same third countries shows where each one has a clear edge. Holy See scores noticeably higher with: Palestine, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Lebanon, Iran, France.Israel scores noticeably higher with: Mexico, South Korea, Vietnam, Chile, Nepal.

The relation between Holy See and Israel has held steady at 7.1 since Aug 2025; before that it was 7.4 (Apr 2025).

Score history

Feb 2022: 7.4/10 Mar 2022: 7.4/10 May 2022: 7.4/10 Jul 2022: 7.4/10 Sep 2022: 7.4/10 Oct 2022: 7.4/10 Nov 2022: 7.4/10 Dec 2022: 7.4/10 Jan 2023: 7.4/10 Jun 2023: 7.4/10 Oct 2023: 7.4/10 Nov 2023: 7.4/10 Jan 2024: 7.4/10 Feb 2024: 7.4/10 Mar 2024: 7.4/10 May 2024: 7.4/10 Oct 2024: 7.4/10 Apr 2025: 7.4/10 Aug 2025: 7.1/10 Oct 2026: 7.1/10
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
7.4 7.4 7.4 7.1 7.1
Nuclear context: Israel possesses nuclear weapons, while Holy See does not. Nuclear capabilities can fundamentally alter the strategic balance and are not fully reflected in the conventional strength percentages below. These figures represent relative conventional strength, not a prediction of the outcome of a real war.

Let's suppose a hypothetical conflict occurs between both countries:

Solo scenario: Holy See vs Israel
Holy See 9.2% Israel 90.8%Winner
Battle narrative

Initial phase

With both the bigger war chest and the stronger air force, Israel is well placed to seize the initiative early, striking key military and infrastructure targets first.

Force composition

Israel can also call on significantly more personnel, counting both active-duty and reserve forces. Israel's advantage extends to naval power as well.

Ground campaign

Holy See's terrain could make a rapid ground campaign difficult: Landlocked, no coastline, and wholly surrounded by Italy; it has no meaningful defensive terrain and relies entirely on diplomatic status rather than geography for its security. Vatican City would likely be a focal point of the campaign: The entire sovereign territory of the Holy See, containing the seat of the Papacy and all of its government and communications infrastructure. Israel's terrain could make a rapid ground campaign difficult: The narrow width leaves little strategic depth, but the eastern high ground overlooking the Jordan Valley has real defensive value, making that terrain a historic strategic prize. Strait of Tiran would likely be a focal point of the campaign: The narrow passage at the mouth of the Gulf of Aqaba that controls sea access to Israel's only Red Sea port at Eilat. Israel's larger population could also support a prolonged resistance.

Prolonged conflict

Israel's stronger economy could help sustain military operations in a prolonged conflict. Occupying Holy See outright would likely prove costly given its terrain.

Overall assessment

Overall, the numbers favor Israel, giving it an estimated 90.8% chance of coming out on top. Turning that edge into a decisive win over Holy See — and holding any ground taken — would still be far from guaranteed.

Simulate a war between Holy See and Israel in the War Simulator.

Want to build your own teams? Try the War Simulator.

Quick answers: Holy See and Israel

NATO: noEU: no 7.1 Relation scoreGood

Are Holy See and Israel allies?

They do not share NATO or EU membership in our data. WorldRelat rates their relationship as good (score 7.14/10).

No shared borderland border

Do they share a border?

No shared land border is recorded between them in our data.

Area (km²)
1
20.3K
Population
801
10.1M

Which is bigger?

By area, Israel is 20,330x larger (20.3K vs 1 km²). By population, Israel is 12,638x larger (10.1M vs 801 people).

#49
#5

Which is more influential?

In the WorldRelat global influence ranking, Holy See is ranked #49 and Israel #5.